I've done both HP5+ and Tri-X @1600 in Caffenol C-L with good results. If I had to choose, I'd probably opt for the HP5+ based strictly on the fact that I can get 100ft of it for about half what Tri-X costs, but in appearance they're really close. No experience with Kentmere 400 at all, but I shot a bunch of the 100 and I liked it.